Islands look interchangeable in photographs and are nothing of the sort in practice. One has a nightlife economy and a coastline of hotels; the neighbour an hour away has three villages, a bus twice a day and nowhere to eat after nine. Choosing badly is the main way beach holidays disappoint, and it is entirely avoidable.
Chapter 01Choose the island, not the archipelago
Within any island group the character varies enormously, usually as a function of how easy the island is to reach. Islands with an airport are busier, better serviced and more expensive; islands two ferries out are quieter, cheaper and require you to be self-sufficient. Neither is better, but they suit completely different weeks.
Decide first what you want the days to look like — beach clubs and restaurants, or empty coves and a hire car with a picnic — and then find the island that matches. Reading the ferry timetable tells you more about an island's character than any amount of photography: four sailings a day means a lively place, four a week means somewhere genuinely quiet.
Chapter 02Ferries, flights and the logistics that bite
Island transport is seasonal and it is the most common source of ruined itineraries. Routes that run several times daily in August may run twice a week in April or not at all, and the timetable for the coming summer is often not published until a few months beforehand. Never book non-refundable accommodation on an island before confirming that the connection actually exists on your dates.
Build buffer days around any flight home. A cancelled sailing in bad weather is normal rather than exceptional, and being stuck on an island the day your flight leaves is a genuinely expensive problem. One buffer night on the mainland before an international departure removes almost all of that risk.
Chapter 03Season, and why the shoulders win
Peak season on any popular coastline means the highest prices, the fullest beaches and, frequently, the hottest and least comfortable weather. Late spring and early autumn typically deliver warm sea, manageable heat, open businesses and a fraction of the crowd. In the Mediterranean, September is warmer in the water than June and far quieter than August.
Check when things actually open, though. Many small islands operate a genuine season, and outside it the restaurants, ferries and hire shops simply close. The ideal window is usually the first or last three weeks of the operating season — everything running, nobody there.
Chapter 04Water safety, taken seriously
Drowning is the leading cause of death among travellers in coastal destinations, and rip currents are the main mechanism. Learn to recognise one — a channel of calmer, often discoloured water cutting through the breaking waves — and learn the response, which is to swim parallel to the shore rather than against the pull, then back in at an angle.
Swim where there are other people, avoid swimming after drinking, and take local warnings seriously even where the sea looks benign. In tropical destinations, ask about currents, marine stingers and tides before entering the water; on many coastlines the danger is entirely invisible from the beach and locals know exactly where it is.
Chapter 05Travelling a coastline responsibly
Small islands run on limited fresh water and limited waste capacity, and visitor numbers routinely exceed both. Short showers, refillable bottles and taking your rubbish back to the mainland where facilities are strained are not gestures; on an island of a few hundred people they are material.
In the water, use mineral sunscreen rather than chemical filters where reefs are present, never stand on or touch coral, and keep a distance from marine life rather than pursuing it for a photograph. Choose operators who follow those rules and eat at locally owned places — on small islands the difference between money that stays and money that leaves is stark, and it decides whether tourism helps the place or hollows it out.
Common questions
Read next